Story
Nov 20, 2026

Moraes sets Supreme Court review of sentencing law after congressional push

The scheduled Supreme Court review puts a sentencing law back at the center of Brazil’s institutional dispute: congressional leaders pressed for a decision, while parties and civil groups argue the measure’s legality must be tested before it can affect convictions.

Justice Alexandre de Moraes has released four challenges to Brazil’s Dosimetry Law for judgment by the Supreme Federal Court’s virtual plenary, scheduled from December 4 to 15. The law revises how sentences and progression through prison regimes are calculated and could lower penalties for people convicted over the January 8 attacks and the alleged coup plot, including former President Jair Bolsonaro.

The timing has drawn differing emphasis. Revista Oeste noted that Moraes acted more than six months after pausing the law’s effects on sentences being served under Supreme Court jurisdiction, and two days after Congress asked him to bring the matter to judgment. When he imposed the pause, Moraes said the full court first needed to rule in the interest of “legal certainty.”

CartaCapital likewise reported that the move followed a meeting in which the presidents of the Chamber of Deputies and Senate, Hugo Motta and Davi Alcolumbre, asked the court to decide the issue this year. But its account stresses the scope of the legal challenges: the cases question both Congress’s procedure in overturning President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s veto and the substance of the measure itself.

At issue is a provision under which, when convictions for a coup attempt and the violent abolition of the democratic rule of law arise from the same conduct, only the more severe penalty would apply rather than both penalties being added together. The law also allows reductions for crimes committed in a crowd context where a defendant neither financed the acts nor held a leadership role.

Both accounts agree that the virtual-plenary ruling will determine whether the new rules can take effect. Any eventual reduction for Bolsonaro or other defendants, however, would still depend on individual case reviews after the court resolves the law’s constitutionality.