Story
Nov 19, 2026
STF’s Dosimetry Law ruling hinges on Moraes’s next move
The dispute over Brazil’s Dosimetry Law has put Congress’s push for a definitive ruling alongside the Supreme Court’s insistence on its judicial timetable. All sides agree that the next procedural step lies with Justice Alexandre de Moraes, while disagreeing over the law’s constitutional standing and practical consequences.
Supreme Federal Court President Edson Fachin says the court could still rule this year on challenges to the Dosimetry Law—but only after Justice Alexandre de Moraes, the cases’ rapporteur, releases them for plenary consideration. Fachin would then decide when to place the matter on the court’s agenda.1
The law, whose application has been suspended since May, changes how sentences are calculated for crimes against Brazil’s democratic rule of law. In some circumstances, it would prevent penalties for a coup attempt and for attempting the violent abolition of the democratic rule of law from being added together, applying only the more severe punishment. That could affect sentence-review requests from people convicted over the January 8, 2023 attacks, including former President Jair Bolsonaro.2
Congressional leaders Hugo Motta and Davi Alcolumbre have pressed Moraes to move the cases forward. In a joint statement after meeting him, they said they had asked for the actions to be released for inclusion on the Supreme Court’s plenary docket, hoping for a final ruling this year; they added that Moraes said he would respond as soon as possible.2
The accounts converge on the procedural bottleneck: without Moraes’s release, there is no hearing date. They also agree that the eventual ruling will determine whether the law can be applied to affected convictions. The difference lies in emphasis. Reporting from the left notes arguments from the federal government’s legal office questioning both the legislative process and the substance of the measure, while the Attorney General’s Office has stressed Congress’s authority to set sentencing criteria.2
Reporting from the right underscores that the law followed a congressional override, and that Moraes suspended it pending constitutional review after challenges brought by the Brazilian Press Association and the PSOL-Rede federation. It stresses that sentence-reduction requests remain on hold, rather than automatically taking effect.3
Even if the court upholds the law, any reduction would depend on individual judicial review—not an automatic revision of sentences.2