Story
Nov 17, 2026
Brazil’s Supreme Court weighs preserving hacked Lava Jato files for the defense
The dispute over the Vaza Jato files turns on two competing imperatives: preserving potentially useful defense material and recognizing that the messages were obtained through an alleged criminal breach. The Supreme Court’s early votes favor keeping the archive while the justices decide its final legal status.
Brazil’s Supreme Court has begun considering whether files seized in Operation Spoofing — including material associated with the Vaza Jato disclosures — should be preserved permanently rather than destroyed. Two votes had been cast against destroying the evidence, while Justice Cristiano Zanin recused himself from the case.1
Justice Dias Toffoli, the case’s rapporteur, has argued that the archive should remain available even though the messages were obtained through hacking. His central distinction is between the alleged illegality of obtaining the material and its potential value to people facing Lava Jato-related investigations or prosecutions. “Nothing prevents its use pro reo, as a means of defense, by investigated persons and defendants,” Toffoli wrote.2
That position frames preservation as a due-process safeguard. Toffoli said destroying the files could impair the right to a full defense by preventing defendants from relying on material in court. He also argued that retaining the archive would preserve evidence needed to establish the underlying hacking offences.2
The case originated in an action by the Democratic Labour Party seeking to stop disposal of the seized material. The court had already upheld a preliminary order by Justice Luiz Fux in 2023 blocking destruction of the files; Toffoli is now seeking to make that protection permanent.2
The debate therefore does not treat the hacked messages as ordinary evidence. Instead, the justices are weighing whether material allegedly acquired unlawfully can still be retained for the limited purpose of protecting defendants’ rights and documenting the breach. Other members of the court were due to register their votes before the virtual-session deadline.2