Story
Nov 17, 2026
Brazil’s judicial council weighs discipline against retired judge over Moraes remarks
The case centers on sharply different readings of a retired judge’s political interventions: Sebastião Coelho portrays them as civic expression and constitutional criticism, while the CNJ inquiry treats the conduct as part of a pattern that could undermine democratic institutions.
Brazil’s National Council of Justice, or CNJ, is scheduled to hear a disciplinary case against retired Federal District court judge Sebastião Coelho over statements and appearances linked to protests against the Supreme Federal Court (STF). The proceeding, opened unanimously in June 2024, examines conduct that began while Coelho was still serving as a judge and continued after his retirement.1
Accounts from both perspectives agree on a central episode: in 2022, at an encampment outside Army Headquarters in Brasília, Coelho called for Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes to be arrested. He argued that Moraes had long failed to respect the Constitution and said then-President Jair Bolsonaro should summon the Armed Forces to carry out the arrest.2
The divide lies in how those remarks are interpreted. Reporting from the left describes the case as examining Coelho’s participation in anti-STF and anti-democratic actions, including activity at the encampment from which supporters later traveled ahead of the January 8, 2023 attacks on Brazil’s three branches of government.1 Former national judicial inspector Luís Felipe Salomão argued that the episodes should be assessed together, saying they promoted an “erosion of the democratic rule of law and incitement of the masses against the legitimately constituted powers.”1
Coelho has presented a different account. When he announced his retirement in an August 2022 court session, he said Moraes’ inaugural address as president of the Superior Electoral Court amounted to “a declaration of war on the country” and said it “inflames, does not unite.”2 Yet he also said he would follow the Constitution, laws and judicial decisions for the remainder of his tenure.
In his defense to the CNJ, Coelho denied that his statements were connected to the 2022 election and said he was retired and “exercising his citizenship.”2 The council’s decision will test whether that defense outweighs the inquiry’s view that a judge’s public conduct, including actions after retirement, formed part of a broader challenge to constitutional institutions.