Story
Nov 16, 2026

Gilmar Mendes says Lula triplex case was political fraud, not a technical reversal

Gilmar Mendes frames the reversal of Lula’s triplex conviction as a response to judicial bias and political interference, while Sergio Moro has maintained that its annulment did not resolve the underlying question over the property.

Brazil Supreme Court Justice Gilmar Mendes has renewed his criticism of former judge Sergio Moro, arguing that the annulment of President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s conviction in the Guarujá triplex case was not a technical procedural outcome but the result of findings that Moro acted without impartiality.

The dispute resurfaced after a federal court ordered the return to construction company OAS of 2.42 million reais raised through the apartment’s auction. Moro said the annulment of Lula’s conviction did not mean the courts had ruled out the possibility that the property belonged to Lula. Mendes rejected that account, calling the portrayal of the decision as based on “formal reasons” detached from the Supreme Court’s findings.

Mendes said the Supreme Court’s ruling that Moro was biased rested on substantial evidence of coordination between the then-judge and Lava Jato prosecutor Deltan Dallagnol. He alleged that messages obtained in Operation Spoofing showed Moro discussing procedural steps with prosecutors, anticipating decisions and influencing the prosecution’s strategy. In Mendes’s words, the episode amounted to a “procedural theater with political-electoral purposes.”

The justice also linked that conduct to events surrounding the 2018 election: Lula’s imprisonment, which prevented him from running, and Moro’s later appointment as justice minister in Jair Bolsonaro’s government. He cited coercive detentions, the disclosure of telephone conversations and the lifting of secrecy around former minister Antonio Palocci’s plea testimony shortly before the first-round vote.

Moro’s position, as summarized in the dispute, separates the annulment from the merits of the property allegation. Mendes takes the opposite view: that treating the reversal as a mere jurisdictional or procedural detail obscures what he calls a manipulation of the justice system intended to remove Lula from the 2018 race. He concluded that the case was “a fraud that, to this day, embarrasses the Brazilian judiciary.”

In 2021, Justice Edson Fachin annulled Lula’s convictions after finding that the Curitiba federal court lacked jurisdiction. That same month, the Supreme Court’s Second Panel found Moro biased in the triplex case; the full court later upheld that ruling, restoring Lula’s political rights.