Story
Nov 16, 2026

Senate’s R$4.96 million phone deal puts 95 iPhones under scrutiny

The Senate presents the proposed Claro contract as a discounted, institutionally necessary renewal of an existing device-loan system, while critics focus on the premium phones and the much larger overall commitment.

Claro has been declared the leading bidder for a Brazilian Senate contract worth R$4.96 million over 48 months, covering mobile service, 425 smartphones, data chips and modems. The result still requires formal approval before the agreement can be signed.

The central point of contention is not simply the phones, but the scale of the replacement. The contract would provide 95 512GB iPhone 18 Pro devices for senators and certain senior Senate officials, alongside 330 Android handsets for management and advisory roles. The devices would be supplied on a comodato basis: Claro would retain ownership and users would return them when the contract ends.

Senate President Davi Alcolumbre has defended the arrangement as meeting institutional needs, arguing that the loan model has been used by the chamber since 2022 and is also common in other public bodies. He has said lawmakers may choose not to use the handsets. From that perspective, the tender is a service contract rather than a permanent purchase of premium devices. Claro’s offer was about R$1.09 million, or 18%, below the Senate’s estimated R$6.05 million budget.

Critics, including lawmakers from different parties, have instead questioned whether the latest devices and expanded allowances are justified. Federal deputy Nikolas Ferreira said he would ask the Federal Court of Accounts to suspend the process, while deputy Tabata Amaral also sought an interruption of the tender.

The new arrangement would replace a 2022 TIM deal worth R$2 million for 383 devices. It raises the total to 425 and doubles the top-tier data allowance from 50GB to 100GB, while increasing the intermediate allowance from 20GB to 50GB. The differing views therefore turn on whether those upgrades reflect operational demands or an avoidable expansion of public spending.