Story
Nov 16, 2026

Moraes Still Holds Most STF Criminal Cases After Inquiry Closes

The reporting portrays the inquiry’s closure as symbolically significant but operationally limited, arguing that Moraes retains an unusually large criminal docket at Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court. The central question is less whether one investigation ended than how the court’s remaining cases are distributed.

The closure of the Supreme Federal Court’s fake-news inquiry has not significantly reduced Justice Alexandre de Moraes’s criminal caseload, according to two reports drawing on court-docket data. Both describe a system in which he remains responsible for the overwhelming majority of unresolved criminal actions, though they cite slightly different totals for pending inquiries.

One account says Moraes oversees 17 of 57 active inquiries — about 30% — and 222 of 229 criminal actions without a final ruling, or 96.9%. It also says he handles 212 of 215 sentence-enforcement proceedings, including matters involving former president Jair Bolsonaro. The report argues that ending the fake-news inquiry “did not diminish” Moraes’s weight in the court’s criminal jurisdiction.

A second account places his inquiry share somewhat lower, at 15 of 55, or 27.2%, while reaching the same conclusion on the pending criminal actions: 222 of 229 remain under his supervision. It stresses that the concentration persists because related investigations and criminal cases continue, rather than because the closed inquiry itself remains active.

The reports also point to the scale and age of the docket. Of the 222 unresolved criminal actions attributed to Moraes, 97 were opened in 2026, according to the second tally. Among other justices, André Mendonça and Cristiano Zanin are listed as the next most frequent rapporteurs for inquiries, while Cármen Lúcia and Nunes Marques each oversee only a small number of unresolved criminal actions.

The distinction matters because the fake-news inquiry, opened in 2019, became a focal point of debate over the scope and duration of Supreme Court investigations. The second report says Chief Justice Edson Fachin ordered its closure after the Prosecutor-General’s Office argued that an inquiry could not remain open indefinitely or continually absorb new subjects. Yet both accounts contend that its end has left Moraes’s broader case portfolio largely intact.