STF decides if Van Hattem becomes a defendant for criticizing Moraes' delegate

Federal deputy Marcel van Hattem could become a defendant in the STF for criticizing delegate Fábio Shor, Moraes' advisor, from the Chamber's podium.

STF decides if Van Hattem becomes a defendant for criticizing Moraes' delegate

TL;DR

  • Federal deputy Marcel van Hattem is under scrutiny by the STF over a complaint filed by the PGR for slander and insult.
  • The complaint stems from Van Hattem's August 2024 speech where he called Federal Police delegate Fábio Alvarez Shor, now an advisor to Minister Alexandre de Moraes, 'absolutely fraudulent' and an 'abuse of authority'.
  • Van Hattem's defense argues that his statements were protected by parliamentary immunity, as guaranteed by the Federal Constitution, which states that deputies and senators are inviolable for their opinions, words, and votes.
  • The STF's decision is seen by Van Hattem and his defense as a critical test for the functioning of Parliament and democracy itself, potentially setting a precedent for prosecuting parliamentarians for speech made in the exercise of their duties.
  • The case is scheduled for virtual judgment at the STF between November 20 and 30, with Minister Flávio Dino as the rapporteur.