Pejotização threatens labor rights and will have limits defined by the STF

Judgment of Theme 1.389 may establish criteria to identify fraud in the hiring of professionals as legal entities; CTB launches national campaign...

Pejotização threatens labor rights and will have limits defined by the STF

TL;DR

  • The practice of "pejotização," hiring workers as legal entities (PJs) while treating them as employees, is under scrutiny by Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF).
  • The STF's ruling on Theme 1.389 will establish criteria to identify fraudulent employment relationships disguised as commercial contracts.
  • The Central of Workers and Employees of Brazil (CTB) has launched a national campaign to combat pejotização, advocating for formal employment and the preservation of labor rights.
  • Key issues include the Labor Court's jurisdiction over suspected fraud, the legality of PJ hiring with employment relationship disputes, and the burden of proof for fraud.
  • If the STF recognizes an employment relationship, workers hired as PJs may be entitled to benefits like paid vacation, 13th salary, FGTS, and social security.
  • A recent court case in Paraná demonstrated how service contracts can hide employment relationships, with elements like goal setting and performance monitoring indicating subordination.
  • The CTB argues that pejotização weakens social protection, shifts responsibilities to workers, and compromises pension contributions and collective bargaining power.
  • The campaign aims to raise awareness, especially among young workers, about the risks of precarious employment and to strengthen union organization.
  • The STF's decision is expected to influence how companies structure contracts and how labor courts assess employment relationship claims.