Fux suspends Dino's decision and reestablishes TSE order on Our Lady of Aparecida posts

Minister orders platforms to resume compliance with André Mendonça's decision within 24 hours; controversy will be analyzed by the STF plenary

Fux suspends Dino's decision and reestablishes TSE order on Our Lady of Aparecida posts

TL;DR

  • Justice Luiz Fux suspended Flávio Dino's decision regarding social media posts about Our Lady of Aparecida.
  • The decision reinstates an order from Justice André Mendonça for the removal of content falsely claiming Flávio Bolsonaro intended to remove the saint's title.
  • Platforms X, Facebook, TikTok, and Google have 24 hours to comply with the order.
  • The controversy began with social media posts alleging Flávio Bolsonaro's intent, which he denies.
  • Flávio Dino had previously allowed content to be reposted, deeming removal justifications insufficient.
  • Fux cited procedural issues, stating the matter should have been a separate case, not consolidated with Deltan Dallagnol's electoral situation.
  • Fux clarified that the TSE decision does not ban criticism, opinions, or satire on religion and politics, only the presentation of false claims as facts.
  • The STF plenary will review Fux's decision.